Teaser Tuesday: Do I Have to Go Medieval?

Yahoo Image Search

I think I’ll do a month of Do I Need to Use a Dragon? (Fantasy Writing Tips) teasers to see what people think.  I can’t put full sections down, so I’m going to grab random introductions.  Hope that works since I would like to showcase this project a little bit.  Enjoy.

Do I Have to Go Medieval?

The original question I was asked was ‘Do I have to use England’ and I was taken aback by it the first time. It never crossed my mind that most fantasy stories take place in a medieval Europe setting. Shows how aware of my literary surroundings I am. The real meaning of this question is about the classical setting of fantasy.

When you think of the genre, you imagine robed wizards, hills rolling into forests, towering castles, roaring dragons, and knights in disturbingly shiny armor. Seriously, what kind of polish do they have in some of these fictional worlds? This setting standard has been around for decades, if not centuries, and many people feel that this is the only way to write fantasy. Before you ask, urban settings get a pass by these gatekeepers as a subgenre, but many will turn up their nose at a non-Earth fantasy book that refuses to imitate Camelot at some point. Thankfully, they are a minority, but this brings up a secondary question:


Hands down. You’re all wrong and you’re all right. Fantasy is a really wonky genre at times because there are so many varieties. Fans will grab their favorite version and act like that’s the epitome of the style. You have adventure, political, social commentary, urban, dark, romantic, magical technology, post-apocalyptic, and so many more subgenres that can cause some friction among fantasy readers. Every part of a story can be criticized depending on a reader’s personal definition and taste of the genre.

People who want a highly political fantasy adventure or one with minimal magic don’t like Legends of Windemere because my stories are adventures with magic everywhere. This doesn’t mean I wrote something terrible or they have no taste in stories. It simply means that while I am a fantasy author and they are a fantasy reader, we aren’t on the same subgenre wavelength. Nothing you can do about it because personal taste is filled with nuance and individuality. Just write your story, hope a reader gives you a fair chance, and prepare to get drawn into one of the many genre debates.

Over the years, I’ve run into many bizarre arguments where I haven’t always been civil because I can get passionate. We all have this issue, so it takes a lot of willpower to remain calm when discussing how a fantasy world works. I’ll be touching on the larger areas in detail throughout this section of the book, but we can do an overview here.

The important thing to realize is that fantasy is very fluid and may be one of the most imaginative genres because you don’t have to work with reality. Earth isn’t necessary. Humans aren’t necessary. Nothing from our world is necessary. You may need a few familiar objects for readers to connect to, but this can be done working under your own rules. The trick is to establish those rules early on because readers will need something to hook them and carry them to when the story really kicks off.

One could say that fantasy is run by guidelines once you step out of the writing mechanics area such as grammar and story structure. This is why you can stumble into a debate about if magic is required for a fantasy story or what level such a thing should be at. People argue over if ‘real’ fantasy has politics or quest-based adventures because the loose guidelines can work with both. I feel the genre is driven primarily by the setting and characters who carry whatever story you give them. Guess you could say this about any genre, but I always sense it’s more so for fantasy. People really take these stories so seriously that fandoms will feud and authors will get drawn into the middle at times. Best you can do is decide on your own definition and set a polite example. That or shout about how such puny mortal discussions are beneath the attention of a god who is in the middle of crafting more of his world. I’m sure that wouldn’t backfire.

About Charles Yallowitz

Charles E. Yallowitz was born, raised, and educated in New York. Then he spent a few years in Florida, realized his fear of alligators, and moved back to the Empire State. When he isn't working hard on his epic fantasy stories, Charles can be found cooking or going on whatever adventure his son has planned for the day. 'Legends of Windemere' is his first series, but it certainly won't be his last.
This entry was posted in Teaser Tuesday and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

26 Responses to Teaser Tuesday: Do I Have to Go Medieval?

  1. noelleg44 says:

    Well, I like robed wizards, hills rolling into forests, towering castles, roaring dragons (especially dragons), and knights in disturbingly shiny armor. So do continue to go medieval on us!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. L. Marie says:

    This is great! I’m so glad you’re also featuring your fantasy writing guide.
    I also love the medieval-ish setting with castles, forests, dragons, knights, etc. My WIP has that setting. But I also love stories set in the East (like Aladdin, Sinbad, etc.). As you mentioned, fantasy is very fluid.


  3. Your last line caused me to laugh out loud. When I look at the differences in Fantasy subgenres I think almost any statement by an author could backfire. Very informative material, Charles. Thanks.

    Liked by 3 people

  4. I so agree with you. Fantasy is a genre of many horizons, and English is popular but by no means the only choice. Imagination should not be so limited!


  5. Reblogged this on Chris The Story Reading Ape's Blog and commented:
    Let Charles know your thoughts, in the comments under his original blog post 😃


  6. Jaq says:

    Harry Potter isn’t Medieval. Just sayin’. 😉

    This question came up in a Facebook group recently. Most of us grow up with children’s stories involving princesses, castles, dragons, and they just get grittier as we get older so it’s a familiar landscape.

    I’m seeing more variety and if you leave Earth, people tend to call it Science Fiction (even Dragonriders of Pern!) so who gets to make the rules?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Science fiction and fantasy tend to get lumped together. I think the ‘rule’ is usually if there’s magic or science behind the world. Magic tends to be fantasy. It does get shaky at some points because you can combine the two.

      Harry Potter is a little medieval. Wizards, robes, dragons, castles, and a European atmosphere are all there. 😁


  7. Great look at your project. Not going to enter any kind of debate. Fantasy can be whatever the author creates within certain parameters.


  8. I agree. Fantasy is made to explore the fantastic. I love settings that are unique or unfamiliar or even just based on cultures outside of Europe. There’s a lot of other interesting places to draw inspiration from.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s