Can You Be Too Experienced for Advice?

Yoda

Yoda is half wrong.

The part that is wrong is about the wise men, which is why I grabbed this meme.  It makes it sound like you eventually hit a point in your life when you don’t need advice.  Many believe this is so, but has anyone ever really hit that point?

I remember my grandparents asking my parents and sometimes me for advice.  They had questions about things that they didn’t understand.  They were certainly wise and experienced in their 90’s and 100’s (grandma made it to 102), which would mean, according to this meme, that they didn’t need advice.  Yet, they were unsure of things and would ask for outside opinion.

A better quote would be the following:

“The only true wisdom is that in knowing you know nothing.” -Socrates

This is the opposite of fake Yoda and answers the post question rather well.  No matter how experienced and wise you get, the reality is that there is always more to learn.  There is always an area that one is not an expert in or new information that changes what you know about things.  A truly wise and experienced person knows this, but it is difficult to fully accept since various aspects of our society work of seniority.  We assume a person who has been at an activity for years knows everything or shouldn’t take advice from someone else.  Well, that’s just asking for trouble.

It is a high level of arrogance for a person to believe there is nothing left to learn.  Even scientists acknowledge that there is more to learn about their fields, which is why they’re always experimenting and researching.  You never know when you’ll stumble onto a new piece of information that enhances your wisdom.  For authors, this is even more so because we need to be constantly growing and learning to prevent our stories from becoming stale.  Challenging ourselves with new tricks and following advice is what makes us better.  It makes our stories more interesting and usually adds a new level to them, but one wouldn’t know if one is too proud to accept advice.

I’m sure some people have rolled their eyes because they can’t believe there are authors out there who don’t take advice.  Well, you just haven’t run into them yet.  Another possibility is that the authors you’ve interacted with haven’t been put in the position of receiving advice.  That can change a person’s demeanor, especially if they are caught by surprise.  The belief the one is too experienced and wise to need advice also means that receiving it can be like a slap to the face.  It’s an unfortunate dark side to people that you don’t notice until it’s reared up at full force.

This mentality is fairly easy to avoid though.  Just keep yourself humble and routinely set out to learn new things.  As long as you acknowledge that there is more to learn, you won’t believe you are too good to grow.  It can be with writing styles, plot creation, character design, or general information.  You never know what you’re going to need down the road, so leave yourself open to advice and absorbing what attracts your interest.  Once you decide that you’re too experienced to listen to anyone else, you’re going to miss out on a lot of useful information.

Want to grow as an author?  Check out Do I Need to Use a Dragon? on Amazon!

Unknown's avatar

About Charles Yallowitz

Charles E. Yallowitz was born, raised, and educated in New York. Then he spent a few years in Florida, realized his fear of alligators, and moved back to the Empire State. When he isn't working hard on his epic fantasy stories, Charles can be found cooking or going on whatever adventure his son has planned for the day. 'Legends of Windemere' is his first series, but it certainly won't be his last.
This entry was posted in Thoughts and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Can You Be Too Experienced for Advice?

  1. L. Marie's avatar L. Marie says:

    A good reminder. Even the most experienced author still needs advice. I know an author who has over 300 published books. She still seeks advice! And on the flip side, I have ezperienced some with far fewer books who reject advice, thinking it beneath them.

    Like

  2. Maybe you have to get old and wise enough to realize when you need advice/help.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Great post. There’s always something new to learn.

    Like

  4. V.M.Sang's avatar V.M.Sang says:

    Absolutely true, Charles. I have 12 books published. I still feel like a newbie. (I suppose compared to the author with 300 books 😊)
    I always put my books through a critique group. It’s amazing how much better they are after the advice I get.
    But it’s important to remember that not all advice is good, and you don’t have to take it if you feel it’s not appropriate, either for your writing or in life. But everyone ought to at least listen.
    And no one is ever too old to learn. It helps keep your brain and you alive.
    About learning! Someone once said, “Nowadays, as they go through education, people learn more and more about less and less. Eventually they will know everything about nothing.

    Like

    • Interesting quote. I wonder what that’s in regards to. There is a lot more to learn than in the past, so it’s hard for schools to get to everything in detail. Maybe that’s what it’s about. Not much time for students to branch out from the core subjects either.

      Liked by 1 person

      • V.M.Sang's avatar V.M.Sang says:

        As an ex-teacher, I know what you mean. I don’t know what happens in the US, but here in the UK, every social problem that occurs, someone will say ‘It should be taught in schools.’ My reaction is ‘What are you going to get rid of so that can be taught?’
        And many things that have been added to the curriculum are things that should, and previously were, taught by parents.

        Like

      • It’s kind of like that here. One issue I see is with history classes. The information keeps piling up, so teachers are forced to spend less time with each topic. One solution has been to split classes in later grades and let kids choose the area they want.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Charles Yallowitz Cancel reply